Razbaeva Ekaterina

Transformation of the goals and content of religious education in England during the late 19th — early 21st centuries

Abstract

The article offers an overview of the grounds on which the importance of the religious component in secular education in the United Kingdom, a country with a mature system of religious education, is based. These include, in particular, a change in the political situation, social expectations, the religious landscape, formed by the rivalry of various denominations and the spiritual state of the society.The features of social dialogue and reactions to modern pan-European transformations are taken into account. Observations are made about the relationship between the value of religious education and the status of the subject, which, in turn, affects all aspects of the organization of religious education at school, including expanding or narrowing the list of religions studied, changing teaching approaches, rethinking the content and others.The purpose of the article is to trace how the status of the subject, goals and attitudes towards the value of religious education have changed in a historical perspective over the course of the 20th-21st centuries.It is concluded that by now there has been a transition from confessional to liberal approaches, in which indoctrination and religious socialization have been replaced by more distant and objective ways of studying religion, as well as increased attention to social goals, such as tolerance and respect for differences and formation of individual religiosity.All these changes led to the fact that the original foundation on which British society was laid and which constituted the Christian faith was gradually washed away. The new recommendations of religious commissions propose to replace the dogmas of traditional religions with an individual set of different beliefs and secular and near-religious views, arbitrarily selected from the entire array of religious knowledge, for each student.

Keywords

religious education, educational goals, multiculturalism, content of religious education, religious education curricula, social cohesion, religious extremism, indoctrination, individual religiosity, world religions, Church of England, Christian values, phenomenological approach

References

1. Alexander R. (2000) Culture and Pedagogy. Oxford.
2. Barnes L. P. (2015) “Humanism, Non-Religious Worldviews and the Future of Religious Education”. Journal of Beliefs and Values, 2015, vol. 36, pp. 179–191.
3. Barnes L. P., Wright A., Brandom A. (eds) (2008) Learning to Teach Religious Education in the Secondary School. 2nd ed. London.
4. Chadwick P. (2001) “The Anglican Perspective on Church Schools”. Oxford Review of Education, 2001, vol. 27, pp. 475–487.
5. Clarke C., Woodhead L. A New Settlement: Religion and Belief in Schools, available at http://faithdebates.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/A-New-Settlement-for-Religion-and-Belief-in-schools.pdf (accessed 17.07.2022).
6. Commission on Religious Education. Final Report-religion and Worldviews: The Way Forward. London, 2018.
7. Cooling T. (2022) “The Commission on Religious Education — a Response to L. Philip Barnes”. British Journal of Educational Studies, 2022, vol. 70 (1), pp. 103–118.
8. Copley T. (2005) Indoctrination, Education and God: The Struggle for the Mind. London.
9. Copley T. (2010) “Religious Education and Social Cohesion: Does History Off er Lessons?”, in M. Grimmitt (ed.) Religious Education and Social and Community Cohesion. Great Wakering, pp. 36–47.
10. Copley T. (2008) Teaching Religion: Sixty Years of Religious Education in England and Wales. Exeter.
11. Cox E., Cairns J. M. (1989) Reforming Religious Education: The Religious Clauses of the 1988 Education Reform Act. London.
12. Education Reform Act (ERA) 1988 Section 8 (3), available at https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/40/contents (accessed 29.04.2022).
13. Erricker C. Religious Education: A Conceptual and Interdisciplinary Approach for Secondary Level. London; New York, 2010.
14. Final Report. Religion and Worldviews: The Way Forward. A National Plan for RE. Commission on Religious Education. 2018.
15. Freathy R., Parker S. (2010) “The Necessity of Historical Inquiry in Educational Research: The Case of Religious Education”. British Journal of Religious Education, 2010, vol. 32 (3), pp. 229–243.
16. Garforth F. W. (1961) “Doubts about Secondary School Scripture”. Religion in Education, 1961, vol. 28 (2), pp. 73–76.
17. Gates B. (2007) Transforming Religious Education: Beliefs and Values under Scrutiny. London, pp. 75–84.
18. Gearon L. (2008) “Religion, Politics and Pedagogy: Historical Contexts”. British Journal of Religious Education, 2008, vol. 30 (2), pp. 93–102.
19. Grimmitt M. (ed.) (2010) Religious Education and Social and Community Cohesion. Great Wakering.
20. Jackson S. (2020) Religious Education and the Anglo-World: The Impact of Empire, Britishness, and Decolonisation in Australia, Canada, and New Zealand. Leiden; Boston.
21. Jackson R. (2019) “Religious Education for Plural Societies: The Selected Works of Robert Jackson”. World Library of Educationalists Series. London.
22. Jackson R. (2014) Signposts — Policy and Practice for Teaching about Religions and Non-Religious Worldviews in Intercultural Education. Council of Europe.
23. Jackson R. (2007) “Some Recent Developments in Religions and Education”. British Journal of Religious Education, 2007, vol. 29 (3), pp. 213–215.
24. Johnson C. (2005) Preface. Teaching Religious Education. London; New York.
25. Jones D. K. (1977) The Making of the Educational System 1851–81. London.
26. Kozyrev F. Gumanitarnoe religioznoe obrazovanie: Kniga dlia uchitelei i metodistov, available at https://lib.rmvoz.ru/bigzal/fjodor_kozyrev/gumanitarnoe_religioznoe_obrazovanie_1-2 (in Russian; accessed 01.09.2022).
27. Lent A. (2001) British Social Movements since 1945: Sex, Colour, Peace and Power. Basingstoke.
28. Levitt M., Muir F. “›The Perfect Pupil″: Changing Aims and Changing Measures of Success in School RE”. British Journal of Religious Education, 2014, vol. 36 (2), pp. 218–233.
29. Making Sense of Religion: A Report on Religious Education in Schools and the Impact of Locally Agreed Syllabuses (2007). London.
30. Moulin D. (2012) “Religious Education in England After 9/11”. Religious Education, 2012, vol. 107 (2), pp. 158–173.
31. “Religious Education in a Global-Local World” (2016), in Berglund J., Shanneik Y., Bocking B. (eds) Boundaries of Religious Freedom: Regulating Religion in Diverse Societies. Springer International Publishing.
32. Almén E., Øster H. C. (eds) Religious Education in Great Britain, Sweden and Russia. Presentations, Problem Inventories and Commentaries. Linköping. Religious Education in English Schools: Non-Statutory Guidance 2010. Nottingham.
33. Revell L. (2008) “Religious Education in England”. Numen, 2008, vol. 55 (2/3), pp. 218–240.
34. Robinson E., Schofi eld C., Sutcliffe-Braithwaite F., Thomlinson N. (2017) “Telling Stories about Post-War Britain: Popular Individualism and the ‘Crisis’ of the 1970s”. Twentieth Century British History, vol. 28 (2), pp. 268–304.
35. Ruyter D. J., Merry D. M. (2009) “Why Education in Public Schools Should Include Religious Ideals”. Studies in Philosophy and Education, 2009, vol. 28, pp. 4295–4311.
36. Skliarova T., Dzheroian M. (2016) “Tsennosti v sovremennom shkol′nom obrazovanii: opyt Velikobritanii”. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia IV: Pedagogika. Psikhologiia, 2016, vol. 4 (43), pp. 9–23 (in Russian).
37. Souper P. C, Kay W. K. (1982) The School Assembly Debate: 1942–82. Southampton.
38. The Durham Report on Religious Education: The Fourth R (1970). London.
39. The Non-Statutory National Framework for Religious Education (QCA/04/1336), QCA. 2004.
40. Toledo Guiding Principles on Teaching about Religions and Beliefs in Public Schools. OSCE/ ODIHR, 2007.
41. Types of schools and their religious education across the UK, available at https://www.interfaith.org.uk/activity/types-of-schools-and-their-religious-education-across-the-uk (accessed 16.05.2022).
42. Viazemskii E. (2010) “Sovremennaia sistema obrazovaniia v Velikobritanii”. Problemy sovremennogo obrazovaniia, 2010, no. 6, pp. 68–83 (in Russian).
43. White J. (2004) “Should Religious Education Be a Compulsory School Subject?”. British Journal of Religious Education, 2004, vol. 26, pp. 2151–2164.

Information about the author

Razbaeva Ekaterina

Student status: Graduate student;
Place of study: St. Tikhon’s Orthodox University for the Humanities; 23B Novokuznetskaia Str., Moskow 115054, Russian Federation;
ORCID: 0000-0002-5733-842X;
Email: erazbaeva@hse.ru.