/

Kostriukov Andrei

About Some Reasons of Failure of Orthodoxy of the Western Rite


Kostriukov Andrei (2016) "About Some Reasons of Failure of Orthodoxy of the Western Rite ", Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriia II : Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoy Pravoslavnoy Tserkvi, 2016, vol. 69, pp. 80-98 (in Russian).

DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturII201669.80-98

Abstract

The article is devoted to the history of orthodoxy of the western rite. Movement to Orthodox Church began in 1930, when catholic priest L. Vinart turned into orthodoxy. This priest was interested in orthodoxy and carried away for a group of clergy. Vinart had many disciples. This group used Latin divine service with some changes. Later the western rite was distributed by two clerics — archimandrite Dionysius (Shambo) and priest Evgraph Kovalevsky. The part of orthodox christians was under guidance of Russian Orthodox Church. Other part was under guidance of Patriarchate of Moscow. However, distribution of the western rite in postwar years was finished. In the article reasons of failure of this missionary project are analyzed. Among this reasons: the absence of aid from Patriarchate of Moscow, the conflicts between the branches of Russian orthodoxy in emigration and great mistakes that was made by archpriest Evgraph Kovalevsky (bishop John).

Keywords

Russian Orthodox Church, Russian Orthodox Church abroad, French Orthodox Church, the western rite in orthodoxy, holy hierarch John (Maximovich), venerable Sylvan of Athos, archimandrite Irinaeus (Vinart), archimandrite Dionysius (Shambo), archpriest Evgr

References


1. Burega V. 2006 “Zhizn' i cerkovnaja dejatel'nost' arhimandrita Dionisija (Shambo)” (Life and Church Activity of Archimandrite Dionisius (Shambo)), in Cerkov' i vremja, 2006, vol. 3/36, pp. 116–162.
2. Zhun'evi K. 2002 “Popytka sozdanija gallikanskoj Cerkvi: Katolicheskaja Pravoslavnaja Cerkov' Francii (ESOF). Istoricheskaja spravka” (Attempt of Creating of the Gallican Church: Catholic Orthodox Church of France. Historical Inquiry), in Al'fa i Omega, 2002, vol. 4/34, pp. 328–345.
3. Kovalevskij E., prot. 1962 “Pravoslavie vo Francii” (Orthodoxy in France), in Cerkovnaja zhizn', 1962, vol. 1–6, pp. 44–52.
4. Kostrjukov A. Russkaja Zarubezhnaja Cerkov' v 1939–1964 gg.: Administrativnoe ustrojstvo i otnoshenija s Cerkov'ju v Otechestve (Russian Church Abroad in 1939–1964: Administrative Structure and Relations with Church in Motherland), Moscow, 2015.
5. Mazyrin A., diak. 2006 “K istorii vysshego upravlenija Russkoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi v 1935–1937 gg.” (To History of High Administration of the Russian Orthodox Church in 1935–1937), in XVI Ezhegodnaja bogoslovskaja konferencija PSTGU: Materialy: V 2 t., Moscow, 2006, vol. 1, pp. 161–172.
6. Niv'er A. Pravoslavnye svjashhennosluzhiteli, bogoslovy i cerkovnye dejateli russkoj jemigracii v Zapadnoj i Central'noj Evrope 1920–1995 (Orthodox Clergy, Theologians and Church Figures of the Russian Emigration in West and Central Europe 1920–1995), Moscow, 2007.
7. Puchkin D. Latinskij obrjad v Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi (Latin Ritus in the Orthodox Church), in: http://www.spasi.ru/biblt/pch1.htm (date: 20.12.2015)).
8. Slesarev A. Pravoslavie zapadnogo obrjada: istoricheskij put' ot cerkovnoj missii k raskolu (Orthodoxy of the West Ritus: Historical Way from Church Mission to Schism) (URL: http: //rusk.ru/st.php?idar=113631 (data obrashhenija 20.12.2015)).
9. Slesarev A. Starostil'nyj raskol v istorii Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi (1924–2008) (Old Style Schism in the History of Orthodox Church (1924–2008)), Moscow, 2009.
10. Kovalevsky M. Orthodox et Occident: Renaissance d’une eglise locale, Paris, 1990.
11. Sidenko A. L’archimandrite Denis Chambault: un Français au sein de l’orthodoxie occidentale, Paris, 2015.

Information about the author

Kostriukov Andrei