Shishkov Andrei

Ecclesiastical Governance in Eucharistic Ecclesiology

Shishkov Andrei (2015) "Ecclesiastical Governance in Eucharistic Ecclesiology ", Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriia I : Bogoslovie. Filosofiia, 2015, vol. 57, pp. 25-38 (in Russian).

DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturI201557.25-38


The author discusses ecclesiastical governance using one of the most meaningful contemporary ecclesiological models - Eucharistic ecclesiology. Conceived by the noted Orthodox theologian Nikolay Afanasyev, this idea became very popular in both Orthodox and non-Orthodox Christian theology. Its underlying concept underlines the role of the people of God who assemble for the Eucharist to partake of the Body of Christ as united in one Body with Christ and thus becoming one Body with Christ. This is, according to Saint Paul, the Church in all its fullness. The unity of the Eucharistic assembly as an empirical manifestation of the Body of Christ requires the local Church to also act as one body. The paper considers two examples of Eucharistic moduls (that of Nikolay Afanasiev and that of John Zizioulas) and examines how the local church acts and makes decisions, and governance is dispersed throughout the body of the local Church. The author points out that in both examples the people play a rather passive role and merely act on that which the bishop decides. The article touches upon a question on possibility/impossibility of negative reception of the presider’s activity by the people. Also the author confirms an idea of principal insensibility of the Eucharistic ecclesiology to any individualization in the decision-making process.


bishop, Body of Christ, church governance, corporate personality, ecclesiology, Eucharist, John Zizioulas, Nikolay Afanasiev, people of God, primacy, power structure


1. Afanas'ev N. 1934 “Dve idei vselenskoj Cerkvi” (Two Ideas of Ecumenical Church), in Put', 1934, vol. 45, pp. 16–29.
2. Afanas'ev N. 1956 “O cerkovnom upravlenii i uchitel'stve” (About Church Administration and Teaching), in Cerkovnyj Vestnik Zapadno-Evropejskogo Pravoslavnogo Jekzarhata, 1956, vol. 60, pp. 18–25.
3. Afanas'ev N., prot. 1999 “«Stacio orbis»”, in Pravoslavnaja obshhina, 1999, vol. 1/49.
4. Afanas'ev N., prot. 1996 “Una Sancta”, in Pravoslavnaja obshhina, 1996, vol. 4/34.
5. Afanas'ev N., prot. Trapeza Gospodnja (Meal of Lord), Riga, 1992.
6. Afanas'ev N., prot. Cerkovnye sobory i ih proishozhdenie (Church Councils and Their Origin), Moscow, 2003.
7. Afanas'ev N., prot. Cerkov' Duha Svjatogo (Church of Holy Spirit), Paris, 1971.
8. Afanassieff N. 1992 “The Сhurch Which Presides in Love”, in The Primacy of Peter, Crestwood, 1992, pp. 91–143.
9. Cavanaugh W. Torture and Eucharist: Theology, Politics, and the Body of Christ, Blackwell Publishing, 1998.
10. Guroian V. Incarnate Love: Essays in the Orthodox Ethics, Notre Dame, 1989.
11. Kantorowicz E.H. The King’s Two Bodies, Princeton, 1997.
12. Lubac H. de. Corpus Mysticum: The Eucharist and the Church in the Middle Ages, Notre Dame, 2007.
13. Manoussakis J. P. God After Metaphysics: A Theological Aesthetics, Indianapolis, 2007.
14. Marion J.-L. God Without Being, Chicago, 2012.
15. McPartlan P.G. The Eucharist Makes the Church: Henry De Lubac and John Zizioulas in Dialogue, Edinburgh, 1993.
16. Nichols A. Theology in the Russian Diaspora: Church, Fathers, Eucharist in Nikolai Afanas’ev (1893–1966), Cambridge, 1989.
17. Papanikolau A. The Mystical as Political: Democracy and Non-Radical Orthodoxy, Notre Dame, 2012.
18. Volf M. After Our Likeness. The Church as the Image of the Trinity, Grand Rapids, 1998.
19. Zizioulas J. Being as Communion: Studies in Personhood and the Church, Crestwood, 1997.
20. Zizioulas J. Eucharist, Bishop, Church: The Unity of the Church in the Divine Eucharist and the Bishop During the First Three Centuries, Brookline, 2001.
21. Zizioulas J. 1999 “Primacy in the Church: An Orthodox Approach”, in James F. (ed.) Petrine Ministry and the Unity of the Church: Toward a Patient and Fraternal Dialogue, Puglisi SA, Collegeville, 1999, pp. 115–126.
22. Zizioulas J. 2010 “The Bishop in the Theological Doctrine of the Orthodox Church”, in The One and the Many: Studies on God, Man, the Church, and the World Today, Alhambra, 2010.
23. Zizioulas J. 2010 “The Development of Conciliar Structures to the Time of the First Ecumenical Council”, in The One and the Many: Studies on God, Man, the Church, and the World Today, Alhambra, 2010.

Information about the author

Shishkov Andrei