/

Lechich Nikola

Between the Monad and the One: at the sources of the ontological dualism


Lechich Nikola (2014) "Between the Monad and the One: at the sources of the ontological dualism ", Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriia I : Bogoslovie. Filosofiia, 2014, vol. 55, pp. 92-106 (in Russian).

DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturI201455.92-106

Abstract

The author of the article describes the philosophical complexity and the ideological coherence of the two earliest philosophical concepts of the One belonging to early Pythagoreans and to the Eleatics, as well as the connection between the concept of the One and the ontological and epistemological dualism. The analysis of the concept of the One in the early Pythagorean school is based on the fragments of Philolaus and on the extant material concerning the science of music and geometry in this school. Part 1 considers the interrelation of two fragments by Philolaus: according to one of them, at the center of the Cosmic Space (Sphere) there is the One which is identified with fire; according to the other fragment, the multitude of things were brought into being by the harmonious corresponding of the limiting and the limitless. Part 2 describes the understanding of harmony, musical consonances, tetraktys, geometrical constructions, the expressible and the inexpressible in the early Pythagorean school. Part 3 considers the concept of the Central Fire. In Part 4 the author demonstrates the connection existing between the ideas of the early Pythagorean school mentioned above and the key topoi of the philosophy of the Eleatics. The author concludes that the amalgamation of monism and ontological and epistemological dualism - one of the richest philosophical, scientifi c and religious phenomena in the history of thought - has its roots in the doctrines of Pythagoreans and Eleatics.

Keywords

ontology, Pre-Socratic philosophers, Pythagoreans, Eleatics, the One, (cosmic) space, nature, the limiting, the limitless, number, origin, dualism

References


1. Vol'f M. N. Filosofskij poisk: Geraklit i Parmenid (Philosophical Search: Heraclites and Parmenides), Saint-Petersburg, 2012.
2. Dobrohotov A. L. 2008 “Vozvrashhenie metafiziki, ili Kakie dejstvitel'nye uspehi sdelala metafizika so vremeni Parmenida” (Return of Metaphysics, or What Real Advances Did Metaphysics Do after Parmenides), in Izbrannoe, Moscow, 2008.
3. Dobrohotov A. L. Kategorija bytija v klassicheskoj zapadnoevropejskoj filosofii (Being Category in Classical West European Philosophy), Moscow, 1986.
4. Zhmud' L. Ja. Nauka, filosofija i religija v rannem pifagoreizme (Science, Philosophy and Religion in Early Pythagorism), Saint-Petersburg, 1994.
5. Zhmud' L. Ja. Pifagor i rannie pifagorejcy (Pythagoras and Early Pythagorians), Moscow, 2012.
6. Baldry H. C. 1932 “Embryological Analogies in Pre-Socratic Cosmogony”, in The Classical Quarterly, 1932, vol. 26/1, pp. 27–34.
7. Burkert W. Lore and Science in Ancient Pythagoreanism, Cambridge (Mass.), 1972.
8. Cornford F. M. 1923 “Mysticism and Science in the Pythagorean Tradition (cont.)”, in The Classical Quarterly, 1923, vol. 17/1, pp. 1–12.
9. Herz-Fischler R. A Mathematical History of the Golden Number, Mineola (NY), 1998.
10. Huffman C. Philolaus of Croton: Pythagorean and Presocratic, Cambridge, 1993.
11. Kahn C. H. Pythagoras and the Pythagoreans: a Brief History, Indianapolis, 2001.
12. Næss A. “The World of Concrete Contents”, in Inquiry: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy and the Social Sciences, vol. 28, pp. 417–428.
13. Schibli H. S. 1996 “On «The One» in Philolaus, Fragment 7”, in The Classical Quarterly, 1996, vol. 46/1, pp. 114–130.

Information about the author

Lechich Nikola