/

Damte David

Researchers of the Soviet Period who Studied the Rapprochement of the Psychology of the Unconscious and Theology


Damte David (2013) "Researchers of the Soviet Period who Studied the Rapprochement of the Psychology of the Unconscious and Theology ", Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriia I : Bogoslovie. Filosofiia, 2013, vol. 47, pp. 101-111 (in Russian).

Abstract

The main theme of this article is the question of how it became possible to see a rapprochement between psychoanalysis and theology. At its beginnings, psychoanalysis was viewed as only psychological theory whose competence did not include the analysis of cultural problems and moral values. However, psychoanalysis continued to develop and concern itself with more and more aspects of the human condition including questions dealing with the psychological nature of religion. An important role in this process was played by the metapsychology of Freud and by psychoanalytical anthropology. It was possible on this basis to study the interaction of psychoanalysis and the various branches of philosophy, and finally the unprecedented rapprochement of psychoanalysis and theology, the latter of which found expression in the works of Pfi ster, Muller-Braunschweig, Jung, Niebuhr, Gerres, Rudin and Drewermann. Western researchers feel that besides the influence of metapsychology and anthropology, the rapprochement of psychoanalysis and theology owed a great deal to the concept of love which is considered a strong creative fundament by the authors mentioned above. Soviet researchers uncovered another side of this question. They held that an entire series of presuppositions of the psychoanalytical theory were based on a very general and often contradictory principle and admit various interpretations both drawn from philosophy as well as from theology. The author agrees with these Soviet specialists on the contradictory nature and generality of the principles of psychoanalysis and examines some concrete examples, particularly as regards the Freudian theory of the origin of religion and morality. The methodology used by the author may be defined as a comparative-historical method employing a descriptive and analytical approach.

Keywords

S. Freud, C. Jung, O. Pfister, psychoanalysis, metapsychology, theology, religion, unconscious, cure of souls, morality

References

1. Boas F. 2006. Metody jetnologii (Methods of Etnology). Mostovaja L. A. (ed.). Antologij a issledovanij kul’tury. Interpretacii kul’tury (Anthology of cultural studies. The interpretations of culture). Saint-Petersburg, 2006, pp. 519–527.
2. Bukina I. N. 1968. Vozniknovenie i razvitie zapadnoj psihologii religii (Genesis and Development of the Western psychology of Religion).Voprosy nauchnogo ateizma, vol. 5, pp. 253–282.
3. Bukina I. N., Popova M. A. 1971. Vozniknovenie i razvitie burzhuaznoj psihologii religii (Genesis and Development of the Bourgeois psychology of Religion). Voprosy nauchnogo ateizma, vol. 11, pp. 113–147.
4. Chebotarev S. N. Ponologicheskaja teorija religii. Opyt postroenija social’no-trudovoj teorii (Ponological theory of the religion. Experience of constructing the social-labor theory). Leningrad, 1928.
5. Daim W. Tiefenpsychologie und Erlosung. Wien, 1954.
6. Drewermann E. Psychoanalyse und Moraltheologie. Mainz, 1983.
7. Ekentajte L. 1976. Frejdizm i sovremennoe hristianstvo (Freudism and Modern Christianity). Voprosy filosofii, vol. 11, pp. 150–157.
8. Frejd Z. Vvedenie v psihoanaliz: Lekcii (Introduction to Psychoanalysis). Мoscow, 1989.
9. Frejd Z. 1989. Budushhee odnoj illjuzii (The Future of an Illusion). Jakovlev A. A. (ed.) Sumerki bogov (Twilight of gods). Мoscow, 1989, pp. 94–142
10. Fromm Je. 1989. Psihoanaliz i religija (Psychoanalysis and Religion). Jakovlev A. A. (ed.) Sumerki bogov (Twilight of gods). Мoscow, 1989, pp. 143–221.
11. Groddeck G. Das Buch vom Es: Psychoanalytische Briefe an eine Freundin. Frankfurt am Main, 1990.
12. Gurev G. 1929. Religija v svete frejdizma (Religion in the Light of Freudizm). Antireligioznik, vol. 1, pp. 40–60;
13. Jevans-Pritchard Je. Teorii primitivnoj religii (Theories of primitive religion). Мoscow, 2004.
14. Jung K. G. Bog i bessoznatel’noe (On God and Unconscious). Мoscow, 1998.
15. Jung K. G. Bog i bessoznatel’noe (On God and unconscious). Мoscow, 1998
16. Kroeber A. L. 1920. Totem and Taboo: An Ethnologic Psychoanalysis. American Anthropologist, vol. 22.1, pp. 48–55.
17. Levi-Stros K. Strukturnaja antropologija (Structural anthropology). Мoscow, 1985.
18. Lukachevskij A. T. Proishozhdenie religii: obzor teorij (Origin of religion: overview of theories). Мoscow, 1929;
19. Majskij V. I. Frejdizm i religij a. Kriticheskij ocherk (Freudianism and religion. Critical essay).Мoscow, 1930.
20. Malinovskij B. Seks i vytesnenie v obshhestve dikarej (Sex and exclusion in the society of savages). Мoscow, 2011.
21. Mamleev V. Z. 1930. Frejd «Budushhnost' odnoj illjuzii» (Freud and his «The Future of an Illusion»). Antireligioznik, vol. 7, pp. 119–124;
22. Mihajlov F. T. 1999. Bog «antihrista» Frejda (The God of Freud the «Antichrist»). Ovcharenko V. I., Lejbin V. M. (eds.). Antologij a rossij skogo psihoanaliza (Anthology of the Russian psychoanalysis), vol. 1, pp. 799–805.
23. Pfister O. Analytische Seelsorge. Einführung in die praktische Psychoanalyse für Pfarren und Laien. Gottingen, 1927.
24. Pfister O. Psychoanalyse und Weltanschauung. Leipzig, 1928
25. Pfister O. Die Frommigkeit des Grafen Lüdwig von Zinzendorf. Eine psychoanalytische Studie. Leipzig, 1925;
26. Pfister O. 1922. Die primären Gefühle als Bedingungen der höchsten Geistesfunktionen. Imago. Zeitschrift für Anwendung der Psychoanalyse auf die Geisteswissenschaften, vol. 8.1, pp. 46–53;
27. Popova M. A. Frejdizm i religija (Freudianism and religion). Мoscow, 1985.
28. Popova M. A. 1977. Psihoanaliz i religija (Psychoanalysis and Religion). Bogomolov A. S. (ed.). Sovremennaja burzhuaznaja filosofija i religija (Modern bourgeois philosophy and religion). Мoscow, 1977, pp. 91–138.
29. Portnov A. A. Shahnovich M. I. Psihozy i religija (Psychosis and religion). Leningrad, 1967.
30. Rank O., Zaks G. Znachenie psihoanaliza v naukah o duhe (Signifi cance of psychoanalysis in studies on the spirit). Saint-Petersburg, 1913;
31. Rejsner M. A. 1924. Frejd i ego shkola o religii (Freud and his School on Religion). Pechat’ i revoljucija, vol. 1, pp. 40–60; vol. 3 (2), pp. 81–106;
32. Reik T. Dogma und Zwangsidee. Eine psychoanalytische Studie zur Entwicklung der Religion. Leipzig, 1927.
33. Rubinshtejn S. L. Principy i puti razvitija psihologii (Principles and ways of psychological development). Мoscow, 1959.
34. Rudin J. Psychotherapie und Religion. Seele — Person — Gott. Freiburg im Breisgau, 1960.
35. Rutkevich A. M. Psihoanaliz i religija (Psychoanalysis and religion). Мoscow, 1987.

Information about the author

Damte David

PDF