Khramov Alexander

Did God create fossils? Notes on the history of an idea

Abstract

The subject of the paper is prochronism, e.g. the teaching which says that the world was created with the appearance of old age. It is shown that the sources of prochronism could be traced to the medieval doctrine of double truth and philosophy of Descartes, who suggested that cosmological theories on the origin of the Universe are purely conditional, while in fact the world was instantly created complete and mature. The idea of apparent, but non-existent past gained much credence during the first half of the 19th century, when paleontological and geological discoveries raised a question on how to square the age of the Earth and the life on it with the six days of Genesis. The hypothesis of prochronism was most fully developed in «Omphalos: an attempt to untie the geological knot» (1857), the book by the English naturalist P. Gosse. During the Darwinian time the interest in this doctrine was shown not only by Christian thinkers, but also by secular philosophers and science fiction writers. Elements of prochronism were also present in the writings of Scriptural geologists in the 19th century and their successors, the young earth creationists in the 20th century. The main objections against prochronism are critically considered. According to the most popular of them, if God had made the world appear older that it is, He thus would have deceived people. But from the point of view of prochronism, the creation of traces of never existed past was necessitated by the logic of causality, which required God to actualize all the consequences of historical epochs skipped by Him. The link between prochronism and the problem of pre-human sufferings is outlined. The conclusion is made that this doctrine, despite being counter-intuitive and rather notorious, is intellectually consistent and immune to the criticism.

Keywords

science and religion, evolutionism, six days of creation, young Earth creationism, occasionalism, Divine hiddenness,

References

1. Bianchi L. (2017) “From Pope Urban VIII to Bishop Étienne Tempier: the Strange History of the ŸDoctrine of Double Truth″”. Freiburger Zeitschrift fur Philosophie und Theologie, vol. 64, pp. 9–26.
2. Darwin C. (1957) Recollections of the Development of My Mind and Character. Moscow (Russian translation).
3. Darwin C. (1950) Selected letters. Moscow (Russian translation).
4. Descartes R. (1989) “Principia Philosophiae”, in Sochineniia [Works], vol. 1, Мoscow, pp. 297–422 (Russian translation).
5. Farmer P. (1996) Behind the Walls of Terra. Moscow (Russian translation).
6. Gould S. J. (1985) “Adam’s Navel”, in The Flamingo’s Smile: Refl ections in Natural History. New York, pp. 99–113.
7. Gould S. J. (1987) Time’s Arrow, Time’s Cycle: Myth and Metaphor in the Discovery of Geological Time. Cambridge; London.
8. Hale P. J. (2012) “Darwin’s Other Bulldog: Charles Kingsley and the Popularisation of Evolution in Victorian England”. Science & Education, vol. 21, pp. 977–1013.
9. Hallam A. (1985) Great Geological Controversies. Moscow (Russian translation).
10. Hitchens C. (2007) God is Not Great. How Religion Poisons Everything. Crows Nest.
11. Khramov A. (2019) “Teisticheskii evoliutsionizm i problema teoditsei” [Theistic evolutionism and the problem of theodicy]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia I: Bogoslovie. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie, no. 83, pp. 26–44 (in Russian).
12. Khramov A. (2019) “Dni tvoreniia i geologicheskoe vremia v britanskoi bogoslovskoi i nauchnoi mysli pervoi pol. XIX v.” [The days of creation and geological time in the British theological and scientific thought of the fi rst half of the 19th century]. Vestnik Ekaterinburgskoi dukhovnoi seminarii, no. 2 (26), pp. 75–97 (in Russian).
13. Klose J. (2021) “Philip Gosse’s Omphalos and the Creationist Problem of Measuring Miracles”. Theology and Science, vol. 19, pp. 406–421.
14. Murray M. J. (2008) Nature Red in Tooth and Claw: Theism and the Problem of Animal Suffering. Oxford.
15. Russell B. (1922) The Analysis of Mind. London.
16. Sayers D. L. (1946) Unpopular Opinions. London.
17. Schellenberg J. L. (2021) Divine Hiddenness and Human Reason. Moscow (Russian translation).
18. Yeo J. J. (2010) Plundering the Egyptians. The Old Testament and Historical Criticism at Westminster Thelogical Seminary (1929–1998). New York.
19. Wittgenstein L. (2010) Culture and Value. On Certainty. Moscow (Russian translation).

Information about the author

Khramov Alexander

Academic Degree: Candidate of Sciences* in Biology;
Place of work: Paleontological Institute of Russian Academy of Sciences; SS Cyril and Methodius School of Post-Graduate and Doctoral Studies; 4/2, Building 1, Piatnitskaia Str., Moscow 115035, Russian Federation;
Post: postdoctoral researcher;
ORCID: 0000-0002-6888-5162;
Email: a_hramov89@mail.ru.

*According to the International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED) 2011, the degree of Candidate of Sciences (Cand.Sc.) belongs to ISCED level 8 — "doctoral or equivalent", together with PhD, DPhil, D.Lit, D.Sc, LL.D, Doctorate or similar.